Method
Two pillars, 50/50 headline. v1.1 adds the watching machine (CS6). v1.2 adds electoral integrity as CS7 inside Pillar 1. It is not a third pillar. Poverty stays in Pillar 2. Older P1 formulas stay on the page.
Pillars
P1 — Attitudes toward civil society
Higher = more closed / repressed civic space. Laws and behavior (de jure + de facto), not speeches.
- CS1 Civic space / CSO
- CS2 Expression & media
- CS3 Association / assembly / NGOs
- CS4 Organized labor (ITUC)
- CS5 Voice / contestation (WGI VA)
- CS6 Domestic control apparatus (v1.1, kept in v1.2)
- CS7 Electoral integrity (v1.2) — not a third pillar
P2 — Socioeconomic distress
Higher = more deprivation, inequality, exclusion, shock. Unchanged in v1.1 and v1.2.
- SE1 Deprivation (24%)
- SE2 Human development (24%)
- SE3 Distribution (20%)
- SE4 Exclusion / youth (16%)
- SE5 Shock & level (16%)
P1 formulas — v1.0, v1.1, and v1.2
The codebook rule is to always publish prior P1 formulas. v1.2 does not overwrite v1.0 or v1.1.
v1.0 baseline
Keep computing forever. Do not overwrite in place.
v1.1 with CS6 18% of P1
Kept beside v1.0 and v1.2.
v1.2 with CS7 16% of P1
Headline for new releases. Weights sum to 1. Electoral integrity is inside Pillar 1, not a third pillar.
| Subindex | v1.0 of P1 | v1.1 of P1 | v1.2 of P1 | Δ pp v1.1→v1.2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS1 civic space | 40% | 32% | 26% | −6 |
| CS2 media | 20% | 16% | 14% | −2 |
| CS3 assembly / NGO | 16% | 14% | 12% | −2 |
| CS4 ITUC | 12% | 10% | 8% | −2 |
| CS5 WGI Voice | 12% | 10% | 8% | −2 |
| CS6 control apparatus | 0% | 18% | 16% | −2 |
| CS7 electoral integrity | 0% | 0% | 16% | +16 |
v1.2 electoral integrity (CS7)
v1.2 adds electoral integrity as CS7 inside Pillar 1. It is not a third pillar. A cooked or missing count is how insecure leadership treats the one civic act that can remove it. Poverty stays in Pillar 2.
P1 v1.2 = 0.26 CS1 + 0.14 CS2 + 0.12 CS3 + 0.08 CS4 + 0.08 CS5 + 0.16 CS6 + 0.16 CS7. Those weights sum to 1. The headline stays 50/50: GLII_ADD = 0.5 P1 + 0.5 P2. Voice is trimmed so the ballot is not counted twice.
What is coded
CS7 is the mean of whichever of these exist, after inversion (high = worse integrity).
| ID | Field | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| EI1 | Electoral Integrity Project PEI 12.0 overall / concept index, latest national contest | Score as 100 minus the PEI score. Carry forward at most 5 years, then missing. PEI 12.0 adds 41 contests from 2025. |
| EI2 | V-Dem v2xel_frefair (clean elections, 0–1) | Score as 100 times (1 minus x). If v2x_elecreg = 0, set 100. |
| EI3 | Freedom House A1+A2+A3 only (electoral process, 0–12) | Invert the sum. Do not add the political-rights total. |
No electoral regime is scored 100, with flag_no_electoral_regime = 1.
That means there is no count, not that the count was stolen.
A Gulf monarchy and a rigged multi-party election must not share a fraud label.
Left out on purpose
- V-Dem polyarchy
- Freedom House political-rights total
- IDEA Global State of Democracy
Those swallow civic space and would turn this index into a second democracy ranking.
How far the headline moves
Approximate movement: delta GLII_ADD ≈ 0.08 times (CS7 minus the old civic blend). A 40-point gap moves the headline by about 3 points. Enough to cross 50. Not a new democracy index.
Four demo cases
Demo cases, not country statistics. The before column is the prior civic blend; the after column is v1.2. Not a full statistical merge.
| Demo case | P1 before → v1.2 | Headline | What changed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Closed-poor, no real count (CS7 = 92) | 78.6 → 80.8 | 71.9 → 73.0, still Q4 | Already at the floor. The ballot confirms it. |
| Closed-rich, managed election (CS7 = 80) | 73.1 → 74.3 | 47.7 → 48.3, still Q2 | Control state. The managed count is why Q2 is not just “rich and rude to NGOs.” |
| Open-poor, messy but real count (CS7 = 40) | 27.9 → 29.8 | 43.0 → 43.9, still Q3 | A 40 is still worse than their very open civic scores, so P1 ticks up. A genuinely clean count (CS7 near 15) would pull P1 down. |
| Mid civic, cooked count (CS7 = 85) | 47.7 → 53.7 | 43.8 → 46.8, crosses into Q2 | v1.1 left them under 50. The ballot is the exit they will not allow. In the demo, P2 is 40, so they become a control case, not a powder keg. |
If that same cooked count sat on a distressed Pillar 2, the cross would be into Q4, not Q2. v1.2 can say the leadership will not allow a count that can remove it, or that there is no count. It still cannot say the leader is illegitimate, or that a high CS7 means the next uprising. A high CS7 with a low P2 is often a managed electoral autocracy that is stable. A high CS7 with a high P2 is the powder keg with no exit.
Episodic press
The press score is the press system, not a famous case.
WikiLeaks and Snowden are flag_episodic_press.
They can add at most 4 points. They cannot set the band.
A constitutionally aligned press that fights the security state and still publishes is not coded as a structurally broken press.
Letter grades (AAA to D)
Every country on the ranking gets a credit-rating-style letter: AAA is the least insecure end of this list and D the most insecure. The letter is not new data and not a new score. It is read straight off the site’s demo rank (1 = most watched, most insecure) with the fixed cut points below. The cut points sit on the band boundaries, so a more insecure rank never gets a better letter, a worse band never gets a better letter, and no band holds letters that are not next to each other. The site checks this every time it is built and refuses to publish if rank, band and letter disagree.
| Grade | Demo rank | Band | Reads as |
|---|---|---|---|
| AAA | 52–54 | Lower | Least insecure on this list |
| AA | 50–51 | Lower | Very low insecurity |
| A | 46–49 | Lower | Low insecurity |
| BBB | 40–45 | Lower | Lower band, upper end |
| BB | 31–39 | Moderate | Moderate insecurity |
| B | 25–30 | Elevated | Elevated insecurity |
| CCC | 17–24 | High (Iraq, rank 23: Elevated) | High insecurity, lower end |
| CC | 10–16 | High | High insecurity |
| C | 5–9 | High | High insecurity, top end |
| D | 1–4 | Very high | Most insecure on this list |
One quirk in the source data: Iraq (rank 23) is in the Elevated band while Nigeria (rank 24, an illustrative v1.2 score) is in the High band. Both are CCC, so neither the rank nor the band is contradicted. Grades move only when a rank moves. Rank, grade and band are illustrative demo values, not an official ranking.
Before 24 October 2026 the site used AAA, BBB and CCC as names for its three computed country types. Those are now called the powder-keg type (closed-poor, Q4), the control type (closed-rich, Q2) and the open type. They are profiles, not grades; their old page ids (country.html?id=AAA and so on) still work.
CS6 children (equal 25% when all present)
FOTN / surveillance items; proxy 100−FOTN
Carnegie / Citizen Lab; 0 ≠ innocent
IMF GFS / OBS — never SIPRI milex
KeepItOn / OONI / NetBlocks user-hours
Need ≥2 children. Do not regional-mean impute. CS6 = mean(available A–D).
Forbidden inputs (R13–R20)
- R13 No SIPRI milex in CS6 (Ukraine / Israel / Poland false positives).
- R14 No ITU Global Cybersecurity Index (rewards having a cyber agency).
- R15 No X / forum volume as a score.
- R16 CS6B=0 means “not in the inventories,” not proof of innocence.
- R17 FOTN ~70 countries; outside that use statutes + V-Dem + shutdowns +
flag_fotn_missing. - R18 Customer of NSO ≠ tyranny; civic-target uplift is mandatory.
- R19 Israel-as-exporter ≠ Israel-as-most-surveilled; code WB/Gaza and 1948 Israel separately or flag.
- R20
OPT_DEFLECTstays weight 0 (companion overlay only).
Missing-data summary (R1–R11)
- R1 A pillar computes only if ≥3 of its 5 subindices exist.
- R2 No composite if either pillar is missing.
- R3 Use listed fallback and set matching flag; never silently swap.
- R4 No regional-mean imputation of civic scores.
- R5 SES may be carried forward ≤3 years (
flag_stale_ses). - R6 Civic inputs stale >1 year = missing.
- R7 PIP fill_gaps off by default.
- R8 Missing ITUC/RSF → renormalize; do not drop China/India.
- R9 Pop <300k or non-sovereign → annex, not headline.
- R10 Keep state collapse with
flag_collapse=1. - R11 Data quality (DQ) = share of core indicators observed; do not headline-rank if DQ < 0.60.
Sensitivity — CS6 weight of P1
Publish rank correlations at CS6 weights 0% / 10% / 18% / 25% of P1 so 18% is not a sacred single choice.
Worked demo — the three computed country types
Already-scaled 0–100 inputs from sheet 04_Demo_formulas.
| Type | Label | Civic v1.0 | Civic v1.1 | Δ civic | Hardship | Score v1.0 | Score v1.1 | Type |
|---|